Max fish per gallon: my formula and why your LFS is wrong

danielp85

New Member
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Location
Edinburgh, UK

Been seeing a lot of 'how many fish' threads lately, and the answers are all over the place. I've been keeping marine fish for 12 years and I use a simple formula that's saved me from crashes more than once.

It's not just inches per gallon. That's outdated. I use a bio-load score based on adult size, waste output, and swimming zone. For example:

  • Small peaceful fish (clowns, gobies): 5 gallons per inch of adult size.
  • Medium semi-aggressive (dwarf angels, wrasses): 8 gallons per inch.
  • Large or messy fish (tangs, triggers): 12 gallons per inch.

Wait, that math doesn't work. Let me redo it. Actually, I use a simpler rule: 1 inch of adult fish per 4 gallons for

DiscusDave

Discus Breeder
Messages
29
Reaction score
0

Wait, did you mean to post the rest? You said "for" and then just stopped lol. I was following the bio-load score thing too, that actually made sense to me until you scrapped it.

Honest question from someone still figuring this out: which one do you actually use? The 5/8/12 gallon rule or the 1 inch per 4 gallons? Because those give really different numbers for something like a kole tang and I don't want to be the guy who nukes his tank off a half-finished forum post.

Also curious how the swimming zone part works into it. Do you count a mid-water fish differently than a bottom dweller even if they're the same size?

You must log in or register to reply here.